Please Join Today!
view counter

Past Chester Community Charter testing head disciplined in cheating scandal

The state's largest bricks-and-mortar charter is operated for profit by a GOP power broker. Its test scores plunged in 2012 when security measures were tightened.

By Dale Mezzacappa and Paul Socolar on Nov 27, 2015 09:09 AM
Photo: Emma Lee for NewsWorks

A former testing coordinator at Chester Community Charter School, the state’s largest bricks-and-mortar charter with more than 3,000 students, has been sanctioned by the state for “systemic violations of the security of the PSSA exams” over the five-year period between 2007 and 2011.

The school was under scrutiny for testing irregularities by the Pennsylvania Department of Education as part of a statewide cheating scandal that broke in 2011.

CCCS is operated for profit by a company owned by Vahan Gureghian, a major Republican donor and power broker who was among the largest individual contributors to former Gov. Tom Corbett’s campaign and a member of his education transition team. During his term, Corbett visited CCCS to tout it as an exemplar of high-quality education for low-income communities.

Now with three campuses, CCCS has drawn more than half the K-8 students who live in the Chester Upland School District. 

The state’s disciplinary action against the former coordinator, Patricia A. Sciamanna, was for violating testing rules during years that CCCS  was struggling to meet federal student proficiency targets used for critical decisions, including whether a charter should be renewed.

The Pennsylvania Professional Standards and Practices Commission (PSPC) suspended Sciamanna’s instructional and administrative licenses, as well as her eligibility to work in a charter or cyber charter, for two years.

It also banned her permanently from ever “participating in, proctoring, monitoring and/or overseeing the administration of the PSSAs.” Although the action was taken in April, it was only recently posted on the PSPC website that tracks disciplinary actions against educators.

An effort by the Notebook to reach Sciamanna through her Facebook page was unsuccessful.

CCCS spokesman A. Bruce Crawley issued a statement on the disciplinary action, saying it is against the school's policy to comment on “issues related to individual staff members.” He did not respond to a request to clarify when Sciamanna started working at the school, when she left, and what positions she held.

The school’s statement reiterated its longstanding position that PDE has made no determination against the school itself in regards to cheating. 

“The PDE closed its review of CCCS in September 2012, with no finding of wrongdoing by the school,” the statement said.

That month, a letter from PDE sent to CCCS, however, cited "overwhelming evidence of testing irregularities" and required the school to adopt strict testing protocols.

CCCS is now one of nine districts or charters in the state on an “open watch list,” meaning that its test administration continues to be closely monitored and supervised by PDE. 

Test scores at the school plunged under new security measures and have remained relatively low since.

A statewide probe

Although much of the public attention around adult cheating on standardized tests in Pennsylvania has been focused on Philadelphia schools, the statewide investigation launched in 2011 probed suspicious results in 38 districts and 11 charters across Pennsylvania.  

One was CCCS.

In July 2011, the Notebook and NewsWorks reported on a state-commissioned analysis showing widespread test score irregularities at dozens of Pennsylvania schools in 2009.  In response, the Pennsylvania Department of Education commissioned a further analysis of PSSA results from 2010 to 2011, then launched an investigation into those whose results was most suspicious. CCCS was flagged multiple times for an unusually high number of wrong-to-right erasures on the test booklets.

The investigation went on for more than a year. The September 2012 letter, sent by then-Deputy Education Secretary Carolyn Dumaresq, recounted how PDE initiated the probe "based on the statistical improbability that the students made these erasures themselves."

But PDE then allowed the school to conduct its own investigation, "which did not yield clear conclusions notwithstanding the overwhelming evidence of testing irregularities," the letter said.

In February of that year, according to the Philadelphia Inquirer, CCCS attorney Francis J. Catania had written to Dumaresq that the school's investigation "uncovered absolutely no evidence of testing improprieties or irregularities" – instead establishing that "improvements in PSSA test scoring are the direct result of hard work, innovative educational programming and persistent preparation by the students, teachers, administrators and parents at CCCS, and not some purported nefarious conduct or 'cheating.'"

Catania suggested the erasures were due to test-taking strategies taught to the students.

Nevertheless, after the school reported the inconclusive results, "PDE returned to complete its investigation," according to Dumaresq's letter. PDE then spelled out strict testing protocols that the school said it would follow, including 24-hour security cameras where the tests are stored and in all classrooms in which students take them. In addition, PDE sent outside monitors to supervise all test administrations.

Through its history, CCCS struggled to make Adequate Yearly Progress (AYP), the test score and performance targets under the federal No Child Left Behind Act. The school made AYP in 2004 but then fell short for four years in a row from 2005 through 2008. 

A fifth year of failing to meet targets would have triggered sanctions under NCLB, including a potential change in management.

The scores climbed in 2009, and for three years in a row, through 2011, they were high enough for the school to earn Adequate Yearly Progress status, an indicator that enhanced the school's credibility in the Chester community. The school's enrollment saw continued growth.

After the strict test protocols were put in place in 2012, proficiency rates at CCCS plummeted by an average of 30 percentage points in every grade and subject. In letters to parents and the media, the school blamed the drop on budget cuts.

Since then, scores have remained low – similar to scores of some Chester-Upland district schools.

That district has been in dire financial straits for decades, most recently exacerbated by its huge payments to CCCS and two other charters. Due to quirks in the state charter funding formula, the district sends $40,000 for each special education student at a charter, a figure that far outstrips any other in the state and has helped to virtually bankrupt Chester schools.

This fall, when it was unclear whether Chester's district schools could afford to open their doors, Gov. Wolf sought a rescue plan for the district in which, among other actions, the payments to the charters for special education students would be lowered to $16,000. The charters, including CCCS, agreed to accept a payment of $27,000 per student as part of a compromise plan that was approved by the courts..  

Little information on inquiries 

Apart from periodic information about individual educators on the Professional Standards and Practices Commission website, the state has provided little information on the findings of its investigations of cheating. Both the state and districts cite confidentiality on personnel matters.

In Pennsylvania, discipline actions against educators are made public by the PSPC once they are final, and they can take years to resolve.

PDE spokesperson Nicole Reigelman said, "The Department takes allegations of educator misconduct seriously. The investigation, negotiation of settlement and/or prosecution of the educator misconduct complaints may require significant time, and there are no mandated timelines for resolving cases. ... PDE does not share information regarding investigative findings."

In 2012, the state Department of Education reported that it was pursuing complaints about PSSA cheating against at least 140 individual educators from schools across the state.

But on the website where it announces disciplinary actions against educators, the state has still only reported a handful of such actions for PSSA cheating, mostly in Philadelphia. And Reigelman did not provide an update on how many such cheating complaints are still outstanding or say whether complaints are pending against other CCCS educators.

The settlement with Sciamanna was the result of a negotiation. The state Department of Education, which brought the complaint in October 2013, had initially sought permanent revocation of her credentials but settled for the two-year suspension.

A review of the state's website listing disciplinary actions against Pennsylvania educators shows most of those implicated in the cheating scandal in Philadelphia received harsher punishments than did Sciamanna. For example, the five Philadelphia School District teachers identified by the state for disciplinary action in 2014 – Radovan Bratic, Michael Reardon, Phyllis Patselas, Alene Goldstein, and Deborah Edwards Dillard – all had to surrender their teaching certifications.


Click Here
view counter

Comments (30)

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on November 27, 2015 7:35 pm

Will she lose her pension?

Submitted by Annoymous (not verified) on November 28, 2015 6:47 am

The dispartity in treatment of Chester Charter is similar to how Palmer Charter was treated by the PA Department of Ed.  Rather than have consequences similar to Philadelphia public schools, the chaters were treated with kid goves and allowed to do an "internal investigation."  While there are still Philadelphia schools with administrators who have not been investigated fully (e.g. former principal at Roosevelt and now principal at Wilson MS - Ms. Ressler),

I'm sure there are other charters that also need to be fully investigated.  June Brown, the notorious theif within the charter industry, stole at least $6.3 million from the taxpayers.  Because of delays, she will now not pay the price.  Chester Charter's private owner has also made a mother load off of taxpayers and students because of an antiquated Chater school law.  

At least the PA Legislature can do is pass new chater school legislation that holds the operators accountable.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on November 28, 2015 11:43 am

Pension? LOL

CCCS does not offer pensions to its employees. 

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on November 29, 2015 7:16 am
PDE spokesperson Nicole Reigelman said, "The Department takes allegations of educator misconduct seriously. The investigation, negotiation of settlement and/or prosecution of the educator misconduct complaints may require significant time, and there are no mandated timelines for resolving cases. ... PDE does not share information regarding investigative findings." Everyone "takes allegations of educator misconduct seriously" but when will the PA department of education own its role and act, I mean, do something effectively to stop. When will it go public with criticism and results of investigations. Too often now, educational misconduct by schools, districts, and individual personnel is cloaked in confidentiality and processes that take too long to reach a meaningful decision. Ironically, the students impacted by the wrongful action of educational personnel and districts never see redress ( in the form of additional educational help such as smaller class size, math and English tutors, reading specialists, counselors, and SAT prep. There is no remediation or restitution to tax payers or students despite personal gain from misuse and abuse of public educational funds. PA PDE needs to demand justice, remediation, and restitution for the students that were directly impacted in addition to criminal or procedural prosecution. Students and taxpayers need more action and less well framed tethoric like "the department takes allegations of educational misconduct seriouly." We need action; and we need it quickly and results of investigations to be made widely public.
Submitted by Ken (not verified) on November 29, 2015 8:03 am

Agree 10000000% with your point.   No one in a position of power is taking this seriously.  No one in a position of power benefits from exposing cheating.  Remember this only came out into the open as s fluke....don't remember the exact details but I thought it was an email inadvertently sent to the Notebook that was never supposed to have seen the light of day??

A decade ago several schools in Camden were caught cheating.  An investigation followed. Obviously adults cheated.  However the final findings did not used the word "cheating"...replacing it with "adult interference".  Wrists were slapped, and as usual only the students were the losers.

Submitted by timeforachange (not verified) on November 29, 2015 2:58 pm

There was one principal in Camden that was used as a scapegoat for his whistleblowing.

Submitted by Paul Socolar on November 30, 2015 10:49 am

The evidence of cheating came out in the open because in 2011 the Notebook submitted a Right-to-Know request for any forensic analyses of PSSA results performed by the state. The analysis is considered a public record and so it is subject to Right to Know rules.

Submitted by Sue Altman (not verified) on December 1, 2015 3:26 pm

Why did NJ state DOE allow these guys to expand last year in Camden and Atlantic City, NJ?? 



Submitted by mery (not verified) on June 27, 2016 12:19 pm

his is a great article thanks for sharing this informative information.


Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on September 1, 2016 6:24 am

This period, computers get really boosted our approach to life, primarily this systems regarding communication. Apart from that, they also play a crucial role in financial evaluate and current administration.


Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on September 1, 2016 6:39 am TELLY viewer offer is escalating. It includes several positive aspects by extending a present-day media with regards to 24/7 smashing news upgrades. There are typically many absolutely free international facts blogs together with channels out there online. Further you'll receive software to produce access that has a restricted programs online. In that way one can potentially reduce satellite television for pc costs and search on the internet fee with regards to more. Chances are you'll enjoy Tv programs or facts online every time convenient available for you.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on September 1, 2016 6:55 am

Scholar healthcare software programs offer lots of advantages at this greatly cheaper, allowing students to repay it independent or letting their parents to add in their children’s professional medical plans in conjunction with little more cost for him or her. Student options give a wonderful choice to ensuring the good health on the children without having to take within the significant variety of extra personal burden.


Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on September 1, 2016 6:58 am

Intended for employment like institutes or perhaps companies you should fulfill unique criteria which often subjects as a way to teaching simply because specific spot. Places like Virginia, Annapolis, accrue as a way to teaching tasks.


Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on September 1, 2016 6:14 am

Dresser Coordinator Systems may very well be lifesavers in the households, especially that the rooms may very well be limited in space. Commonly, today homes have gotten smaller and they are generally built in conjunction with less bedroom, as populations develop and as a consequence houses are designed smaller to back up more persons.


Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on September 1, 2016 6:30 am

Hybrid car vehicles are sent in the manufacturer in conjunction with tires of which work in many conditions, get decreased neighborhood resistance, and cause fuel efficiency. This style of tire is a low-rolling weight tire. If the time will involve replace the exact tires with your hybrid, stay with such a tire.


Submitted by Pervez74 (not verified) on October 29, 2016 11:30 am

Terrific not to mention outstanding put up. I recently came across close to this much instructive, as to what I just was basically fully interested in. Nowadays follow this payday loans oceanside Thanks a lot for the purpose of many of these put up not to mention why not keep writing.

Submitted by waw (not verified) on December 3, 2016 2:40 am

اهلا بكم في افضل موقع العاب تلبيس ومكياج جديدة هيا الان استمتعو في موقعنا الدي يضم اجمل و اروع العاب تلبيس بنات

ايضا يمكنكم الاستمتاع باروع العاب طبخ بنات ,,,,,

Play Now friv Games

Submitted by feliz navidad 2016 (not verified) on December 19, 2016 1:27 am

happy new yaer Feliz Navidad 2016 thanks

Submitted by best camera under (not verified) on May 1, 2017 2:21 am
The Caucus of Working Educators, which is trying to topple the long-dominant Collective Bargaining (CB) Team for leadership of the Philadelphia Federation of Teachers, is protesting the union's election procedures -- or the lack of them so far.
Submitted by Thidoin (not verified) on July 15, 2017 3:56 am

I love to browse the list of newspapers in the world. It turns out that in every country is (deliberate or not) filing information. To really know what is going on in the world you have to go through several newspapers from different countries, from different continents.

Rithven Inspire


Things to do in

blog REP

free steam games keys giveaway


I love to read the economist. This is a great online newspaper. Should be on the list of world newspapers that meet the strictest standards: an interesting and transparent article !!

Submitted by naveen sharma (not verified) on December 20, 2017 2:13 am

here is best collection of happy new year gif best new year wishes new year wishes messages

new year wishes for friends

Submitted by RichardDo (not verified) on February 7, 2018 3:20 am
Phẫu thuật thu gọn cánh mũi ở đâu đẹp tại Hà Nội:

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

By using this service you agree not to post material that is obscene, harassing, defamatory, or otherwise objectionable. We reserve the right to delete or remove any material deemed to be in violation of this rule, and to ban anyone who violates this rule. Please see our "Terms of Usage" for more detail concerning your obligations as a user of this service. Reader comments are limited to 500 words. You are fully responsible for the content that you post.

Follow Us On

Read the latest print issue

Philly Ed Feed

Recent Comments


Public School Notebook

699 Ranstead St.
Third Floor
Philadelphia, PA 19106
Phone: (215) 839-0082
Fax: (215) 238-2300

© Copyright 2013 The Philadelphia Public School Notebook. All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Usage and Privacy Policy