Please Join Today!
view counter

Why Philadelphia needs a 'Citizens' Commission for Education'

By Susan Gobreski on Oct 30, 2015 04:00 PM

We need a better mechanism for authentic public participation in the governance of the state-controlled School District of Philadelphia.

Education Voters has launched a new effort calling for the creation of a “Citizens’ Commission for Education” in Philadelphia.

Our current structure is inadequate. “We the people” really don’t have a way to ask questions about what is going on with schools. We can go to School Reform Commission meetings and make comments or ask questions, but that is all – speakers have no certainty of a response.

A formal committee convened by City Council could be a space where hearings can be held, issues can be explored, and questions can be asked with some expectation of an answer. Such an entity could help give citizens a way to explore how public education is functioning, how it is being run and whether it is meeting community needs. It could give them a way to talk about issues, even if the SRC or District administration is not talking about them.

The committee could look more closely at school closings, vendor contracts, and property sales. It could hold hearings on school discipline policy, the role of charter schools, the condition of buildings, or the admissions process, helping to ensure those conversations are happening in a transparent and public way. It could educate itself, and all of us, on critical issues such as how poverty and trauma affect learning and guide decisions based on what we learn. A commission could help explore how to better align city services and create authentic community schools that meet the needs of children and families.

Council has stepped up in the last few years, responding to community desire for more financial support for the schools and greater engagement. We are seeing leadership there, and that is good. The new intergovernmental cooperation agreement on finances and data is also a leap forward.

However, Council has many obligations, and it is being pulled in multiple directions. In fact, a singular focus on this issue could be to the detriment of other important quality-of-life issues in the city.

A Citizens’ Commission could be a tool that marries a stronger role for city government officials and an expanded role for citizens. It could advise and assist City Council (and the mayor) in exercising review and oversight of the public schools and the financial investment we provide. And it could happen quickly instead of waiting for several years.

We can't let the same people who have had the power in the past decide the future. It is time to change not just the players, but the game. 

Education Voters has already suggested that it is time to look for new governance models for the School District of Philadelphia. Last fall, we suggested a new governance structure to replace the SRC, comprising a mix of appointed and elected officials. That conversation needs to happen, but governance is not a proven method of reform, so just changing the governance structure again is not a solution. We must also stop the politics of churn and disruption.

We need a true civic dialogue about what we need for and from our schools and how any governance model can accomplish that. A commission could take on the task of looking into what our community’s needs are and how to meet those needs, instead of starting with the question “Who gets to decide what to do next?”

To be effective and credible, the commission should have an array of diverse, representative stakeholders that includes parents, community members, students, educators, and a selection of policy people, financial experts and people with community planning credentials, in addition to Council members. It wouldn’t necessarily need to be a permanent body; it could be a “special committee” or task force.

With its budgetary role and power to hold hearings, City Council is uniquely positioned to directly engage the School Reform Commission and School District administration. Therefore it is uniquely positioned to provide a mechanism to create meaningful and robust public participation.

We are getting ready to welcome a new mayor and new members to Council, so now is a perfect time to usher in a new era of citizen involvement and access to information and decision-making.  As we enter a new budget cycle, it would be good to have a stronger base of widely available information to inform those decisions – and to talk about the priorities and direction of the District, instead of just its survival. This entity could facilitate that conversation. 

Will a new body be a panacea? Of course not. It will only work if it is a workhorse group, not a beauty pageant. We’ll need to work together to give it some thought and clear direction and work out the details.


Susan Gobreski is the executive director of Education Voters Pennsylvania.

The opinions expressed are solely those of the author.

Click Here
view counter

Comments (34)

Submitted by Rich Migliore (not verified) on October 31, 2015 3:59 pm

Thanks Susan. A lot of good ideas. We certainly do need a "true civic dialogue?" I certainly wish the SRC would lead a true civic dialogue and embrace the fact that they are supposed to be a democratic body serving the civic virtue of public education. Too often private interests are served rather than the public good, and I have said much about that in the past.

May I just say one thing which, you know, I deeply believe in? Democracy is the cure for the ills that plague our supposedly public schools. No matter how we twist it, we cannot escape the imperative of Democracy for Our schools. 

I believe what we need most of all --is an elected school board. 

Submitted by ARL (not verified) on October 17, 2016 4:17 am
Jual Green Coffee, harga terbaik dan menerima pengiriman ke seluruh wilayah di Indonesia.
Submitted by moet36 (not verified) on November 29, 2016 10:01 pm

có kết quả cực kỳ có lợi đưa hai thể nhanh còn thuốc uống kéo dài thời gian quan hệ lại nhưng mà ko nên áp dụng trường hợp tình trạng xuất tinh nhanh liên tục sẽ

Submitted by dien dan game (not verified) on December 5, 2016 10:55 pm

gia đình cãi nhau cũng chỉ vì ông chồng không chịu đi mua thuốc cường dương về để tiếp đã bà vợ. câu chuyện hài

Submitted by dien dan game (not verified) on December 5, 2016 10:19 pm

toi muon hoi dia chi thue may photocopy gia re hang may photocopy xerox tot nhat o dau?

Submitted by happy new year images (not verified) on December 8, 2016 12:21 am

    Wishing you a New Year  that brings luck and prosperity that fills your home with joy and spirit, Happy New year images

Submitted by SKF (not verified) on April 4, 2017 11:30 am

Nói đến việc sản xuất vòng vi và các loại ổ lăn. Sở dĩ SKF được nhiều người ưa chuộng và tồn tại lâu năm trên thị trường thiết bị linh kiện chính là nhờ yêu cầu cao trong tiêu chuẩn của mình. Các loại vòng  bi của hãng đều được sản xuất với một tiêu chuẩn cao và cho chất lượng tuyệt vời, nổi bật trên thị trường và khả năng sử dụng lâu dài.

Submitted by tienamphu (not verified) on April 4, 2017 11:24 am

mua tiền âm phủ hà nội đẹp chất lượng hãy tìm tới cơ sở Quyết Vượng tại Làng Âm Phủ. Đơn vị chuyên bán các loại tiền polymer âm phủ hà nội,đô la âm phủ mẫu mã đẹp

Submitted by các món chay ngon (not verified) on April 5, 2017 12:47 am trang we chuyên tổng hợbp về cách làm bánh kem tại nhà cực ngon mà vừa đơn giản. Cách làm nhanh chóng ai cũng có thể làm đư

Submitted by vệ sinh nha ở quận 2 (not verified) on April 5, 2017 3:26 am

Ra mắt dịch vụ vệ sinh nhà ở tại công ty sao việt. Đây là 1 trong các dịch vụ uy tín đang được khá nhiều khách hàng quan tâm và yêu mến, cho nên nếu ai đang có nhu cầu làm vệ sinh nhà ở thì hãy liên hệ với chúng tôi tại website

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on April 21, 2017 6:29 am

- The product has special polymer additives, so the Far East tile adhesives have high adhesion

<a href=""></a>

- Vien Dong brick adhesive is produced by industrial technology so the quality is always guaranteed, we are committed to the works are durable over time.

- Slip is equal to "0", so it is convenient to install on the ceiling or straight surface, ensuring the highest safety.

- Fast execution, save time and labor, shorten the time to complete the works but still ensure the aesthetics and efficiency.

Submitted by ion kiem (not verified) on May 3, 2017 12:44 am

thực hư về việc nước ion kiềm chữa bệnh có đúng như người ta quảng cáo. vậy nước ion kiềm là gì . Xem thêm tại website :

Submitted by Sống đẹp, Sống khỏe, Sống có ích (not verified) on May 3, 2017 5:30 am

Làm đẹp - cách chọn mỹ phẩm tốt phù hợp cho từng loại da khác nhau, cách phối đồ hợp thời trang

Submitted by blogloichuc (not verified) on May 4, 2017 11:42 pm

Bật mí các câu chúc ngủ ngon hay ai cũng thích, câu chúc ngọt ngào lãng mạn đầy tình cảm ai nghe xong cũng phải mê mệt. Xem nhiều câu chúc ngũ ngon ngay tại website

Submitted by son (not verified) on May 8, 2017 9:42 pm

Chia sẽ những lời chúc mừng sinh nhật người yêu hay và tràn đầy tình cảm ý nghĩa cho các cặp đôi đang yêu nhau. Những lời chúc độc đáo hóm hĩnh đảm bảo ai cũng thích

Submitted by nick lien quan (not verified) on May 13, 2017 8:41 am

Truy kích trung quốc game hay mà người chơi không thể bỏ qua trong dịp này đúng không nào

Code truy kích bạn đã nhận hay chưa

Submitted by sai sree (not verified) on May 18, 2017 1:34 am

memorial day greetings  Memorial Day is a central holiday observed every year on the last Monday of May in the United States. 

Memorial Day is a time to honor, reflect and remember those who’ve made the ultimate sacrifice. happy memorial day images
We are celebrating Memorial Day to remember for those who lost their life to serving for the country. 
Memorial Day was originally known as Decoration Day and initiated to honor the soldiers for the Union
 and confederate armies who died during the American Civil War.
Submitted by sâm hàn quốc (not verified) on September 9, 2017 12:58 am

Cửa Hàng sâm hàn quốc Sâm Yến Thịnh Phát xin giới thiệu các loại banh trung thu yen sao 2017 đặc biệt thơm ngon. Bánh trung thu yến sào bán tại cửa hàng là sản phẩm của công ty nhà nước Yến Sào Khánh Hòa. Đây là các sản phẩm được sản xuất trên một quy trình khép kín đảm bảo các sản phẩm đạt tiêu chuẩn nhan sam han quoc về mặt an toàn hợp vệ sinh cũng như có chất lượng hết sức thơm ngon và đặc biệt. Các loại bánh trung thu được đóng gói bằng các loại bao bì hết sức đẹp mắt và trang trọng, có thể làm quà để tặng cho người thân và gia đình trong dịp trung thu.

Submitted by bánh trung thu cao cấp (not verified) on September 13, 2017 5:04 am

Cửa Hàng bánh trung thu ngon Sâm Yến Thịnh Phát xin giới thiệu các loại bánh trung thu yến sào 2017 đặc biệt thơm ngon. bảng giá bánh trung thu bán tại cửa hàng là sản phẩm của công ty nhà nước Yến Sào Khánh Hòa. Đây nam lim xanh quang nam là các sản phẩm được sản xuất trên một quy trình khép kín đảm bảo các sản phẩm đạt tiêu chuẩn về mặt an toàn hợp vệ sinh cao linh chi cũng như có chất lượng hết sức thơm ngon và đặc biệt.

Submitted by tiendiaphu (not verified) on May 23, 2017 3:54 am

tiền vàng là sản phẩm cúng không thể thiếu trong mỗi dịp rằm hoặc ngày mồng 1 hằng tháng

Submitted by sai kumar (not verified) on May 25, 2017 2:40 am

memorial day wallpapers

memorial day quotes 2017,famous memorial day quotes,memorial day 2017 quotes,best memorial day quotes,

all are referece from:


Submitted by lakshmi (not verified) on May 27, 2017 1:30 am
Best Happy Father's Day 2017 Images, Photos, Wallpapers, Pics, Profile Pictures For Facebook Whatsapp. 
The happy father's day messages is here with a great collection of Best Happy Father's Day 2017 Images, 
Photos, Wallpapers, Pics, Profile Pictures For Facebook Whatsapp.Happy Fathers Day
 You can also share these father's day 2017 images, wallpapers, father's day 2017 profile pictures,
 father's day facebook profile pictures, father's day wishing images anywhere on internet.
Submitted by rang veneer (not verified) on May 29, 2017 11:16 am

Có thể nói bọc răng sứ thẩm mỹ an toàn tại Hà Nội hiện nay là một trong những giải pháp phục hình vô cùng an toàn và nhanh chóng được rất nhiều bệnh nhân lựa chọn để khắc phục các khiếm khuyết trên khuôn hàm. Bọc răng toàn sứ titan sẽ giúp bệnh nhân cải thiện được tính thẩm mỹ vô cùng hoàn hảo

Submitted by Willson (not verified) on June 16, 2017 6:40 am

Yahoo Email is one of the most famous email services. Millions of people are using across the world. But some time Yahoo user facing some technical issues, like they cannot configure your Yahoo mail to any Android devices or unable to access yahoo mail on android devices in this situation you can take some help regarding your problems. 

Yahoo Technical Support Customer Services Helpline toll-free Number Yahoo Technical Support Customer Services Helpline toll-free Number Yahoo Technical Support Customer Services Helpline toll-free Number Yahoo Technical Support Customer Services Helpline toll-free Number Yahoo Technical Support Customer Services Helpline toll-free Number

Submitted by Xuattinh (not verified) on June 22, 2017 4:51 am

Thuốc kéo dài thời gian quan hệ Gravimax chống xuất tinh sớm dành cho nam, dương vật cương cứng được hỗ trợ và đạt được cực khoái khi quan hệ tình dục lâu hơn

Submitted by thoitranggym (not verified) on June 22, 2017 4:27 am

Quần áo tập gym cho nữ tại thoitranggym sẽ giúp bạn chọn lựa các phong cách thời trang khác nhau cũng như có 1 bộ quần áo đẹp giúp bạn vào phòng tập gym cách thoải mái nhất.

Submitted by ravanth rocey (not verified) on July 1, 2017 12:56 am

happy parents day 2017 quotes

parents day quotes

happy parents day 2017


Submitted by uma siva (not verified) on July 1, 2017 12:22 am

parents day quotes

parents day quotes

friendship quotes


Submitted by sravanthi (not verified) on July 1, 2017 12:16 am

parents day quotes


happy parents day 2017


Submitted by sravanthi (not verified) on July 1, 2017 12:43 am

parents day quotes

parents day quotes

parents day quotes

Submitted by aptoide apk (not verified) on November 2, 2017 5:43 am

Submitted by Bất động sản (not verified) on December 11, 2017 11:00 pm

Dự án Gem Riverside Quan 2 toa lac ngay trung tam quan 2, mat tien duong cao toc Long Thanh - Dau Giay

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on February 24, 2018 7:50 am

Thank you for sharing this information. Love your blog post. Please Keep updating. You can also visit our blog for women's day 2018 images Women's Day Images Happy Women's Day 2018

Submitted by playview iphone (not verified) on April 21, 2018 5:49 am

PlayView application is one of the best apps for watching movies, T.V shows in HD quality and also Live shows on your device

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

By using this service you agree not to post material that is obscene, harassing, defamatory, or otherwise objectionable. We reserve the right to delete or remove any material deemed to be in violation of this rule, and to ban anyone who violates this rule. Please see our "Terms of Usage" for more detail concerning your obligations as a user of this service. Reader comments are limited to 500 words. You are fully responsible for the content that you post.

Follow Us On

Read the latest print issue

Philly Ed Feed


Public School Notebook

699 Ranstead St.
Third Floor
Philadelphia, PA 19106
Phone: (215) 839-0082
Fax: (215) 238-2300

© Copyright 2013 The Philadelphia Public School Notebook. All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Usage and Privacy Policy