Donate today!
view counter

Does the District need another special admission middle school?

By Christine Carlson on Jun 11, 2015 02:02 PM

Every spring, parents of 4th graders anxiously wonder whether their child will be accepted into Masterman or GAMP or another of the city’s seven special admission middle schools and programs. What follows when the letters finally arrive are either triumphant smiles or downcast eyes.

Then begins the exodus, as neighborhood schools across the city are stripped of their top students.

Because these special admission schools have the highest scores, most parents think they are a better option for their child. They don’t want to keep their children in their current school for the middle grades, even if they are fine schools or if they know that child psychologists consider K-8 schools the best school type for adolescent development.

This year, one the District’s highest-ranking high schools Carver Engineering & Science, announced that they would soon open their own special admission middle school. This may come as welcome news to many parents. But if this trend follows the path of our District high schools, it will segregate more of our students at an even younger age.

There was a time when Philadelphia’s neighborhood high schools shone. With the exception of Central (for boys) and Girls' High, there were no special-admit high schools and with few exceptions, all of the neighborhood kids attended their neighborhood high school.

Students might have been on different academic tracks, but they went to school together. They ate lunch together, they played sports together, and they made music together. Students on lower tracks saw the possibilities of what they could achieve by being exposed to their peers on higher tracks. They in turn could motivate their lower-performing peers. The neighborhood high school universe was balanced, and everyone was better off because of it.

In the last two decades, as the District opened more special admission high schools, an increasing number of academically thriving students were sucked out of the neighborhood schools. The most vulnerable students were left behind in half-empty, cavernous spaces. Despite the fact that many neighborhood schools have great leadership, they have been left in an untenable position of dealing with a culture of low expectations, violence, and hopelessness.

Special admission high schools are great places of learning and give students many opportunities. But we now have a segregated system, where excellent students and average or struggling students have no contact with one another. Were we to continue this trend with our middle schools, what would happen? Won't we eventually have the same two-tiered system? And what’s next, special admission 1st grades?

Creating new middle schools is not the best use of the District’s meager resources. Unless these special admission schools attract students from private or charter schools, those who aren't part of the District's system, students will be pulled from seats in elementary schools throughout the city. The result will be more empty seats in more underutilized schools -- the pressure to close neighborhood schools can only continue.

Imagine if all of the financial and human resources now being used in the special admission middle schools, present and future, were invested in the middle grades of our existing K-8 schools? Blasphemy, I know! But there’s something to be said about concentrating, rather than diluting, our resources.

My husband and I send our children to our neighborhood elementary school, and we’ll keep them there through 8th grade. But they will attend special admission high schools or leave the District, because, right now, the division that exists between special admission and neighborhood high schools is just too deep.

I’d like to think that there is a solution that I could help tackle, but the task seems insurmountable. I’d hate to see the same kind of gap happen to our middle schools as well.           

Editor's note: A previous version of this commentary incorrectly stated that an SLA planned middle school would be special admission. It also incorrectly stated the number of special admission middle schools and programs. There are currently seven, with an eighth opening in the fall


Christine Carlson is a public school parent and the founder of the Greater Center City Neighborhood Schools Coalition.

The opinions expressed are solely those of the author.

Click Here
view counter

Comments (13)

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on June 11, 2015 3:16 pm

You have an excellent point. The money for these schools came from PSP. It's interesting that we are able to see through Gleason's 'alruism' when it comes to charters and religious schools. It wasn't necessarily so obvious when it comes to money for our public schools. But his mission remains the same, strip the neighborhood schools of top students and resources which will force them to close.

Again, excellent insight.

Submitted by Annony (not verified) on June 11, 2015 4:32 pm

I agree with the point - special admission high schools have created a gigantic academic stratification in the District.  (We can thank Vallas for increasing the number of special admit high schools exponentially.  While some were created as "desegergation" schools, the huge expanse and demolition of neighborhood schools was exasperated under Vallas.)

That said, there are other middle schools with admission requirements and/or procedures.  AMY Northwest, MYA, AMY at James Martin, Conwell Middle Magnet, and Grover Washington MS, have admission requirements or procedures.  


Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on June 14, 2015 9:38 pm

AMY at James Martin and MYA do not have requirements. They are lottery based and anyone can apply as long as it is before the deadline.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on June 11, 2015 4:08 pm

The SLA-MS is not a special admission school.  It wil be a neighborhood middle school for Powel Elementary, a neighborhood K-4 school. Many students at Powel are unable to find suitable District middle school placements and leave for Charters, Private and Catholic Schools.  The creation of this neighborhood middle school is not to take students out of other schools, instead it is intended to build on a well performing elementary school and keep students in District schools. 



Submitted by Annony (not verified) on June 11, 2015 9:43 pm

It will make Powell another Penn Alexander - housing prices will sky rocket and a very select group will be able to attend the neighborhood school. Wht is wrong with MYA? If Powell students don't get into Masterman, they go to MYA.

Submitted by anonymous (not verified) on June 11, 2015 10:57 pm

What is wrong with MYA?

Submitted by anonymous (not verified) on June 11, 2015 10:25 pm

What is wrong with MYA?

Submitted by ConcernedRoxParent (not verified) on June 11, 2015 5:10 pm

There should be no middle schools.  There should be K-8 and then High Schools.  Too much transition is not good.



Submitted by Annony (not verified) on June 12, 2015 10:59 am

How do we know the enrollment of the SLA Middle School?  Will Powell students who don't get into Masterman be guaranteed a "seat?"  Will it then have student apply similar to GAMP and Masterman?  Has anything been decided other than to pay a principal to prepare the school in 2015-2016 and open in 2016-2017?  (This is a huge luxury - a year of planning. That does NOT happen in neighborhood schools.)

Submitted by Education Grad ... on June 12, 2015 8:12 pm


Could you cite some research from child psychologists regarding K-8 schools being better for adolescent development than middle schools?

Educator of Great Students


Submitted by (not verified) on December 5, 2016 3:37 am
A few organizations will even go so far as to contact relatives with the reason that they are attempting to contact you - to a great extent a mental amusement. You ought to know, however, that despite everything you have rights, notwithstanding with regards to a defaulted advance.
Submitted by Roja (not verified) on December 23, 2016 9:27 am

We have received check out your website write-up as well as once I experienced an amazingly beneficial and the knowledgeable suggestions through the entire website. Now click on the following Payday Loans Oceanside Thank you helpful performs the job. Enjoy it.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

By using this service you agree not to post material that is obscene, harassing, defamatory, or otherwise objectionable. We reserve the right to delete or remove any material deemed to be in violation of this rule, and to ban anyone who violates this rule. Please see our "Terms of Usage" for more detail concerning your obligations as a user of this service. Reader comments are limited to 500 words. You are fully responsible for the content that you post.

Follow Us On

Read the latest print issue

Philly Ed Feed

Recent Comments


Public School Notebook

699 Ranstead St.
Third Floor
Philadelphia, PA 19106
Phone: (215) 839-0082
Fax: (215) 238-2300

© Copyright 2013 The Philadelphia Public School Notebook. All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Usage and Privacy Policy