Please Join Today!
view counter

April 2013 Vol. 20. No. 5 Focus on Getting to Graduation

Theme articles

9th grade is still where most fall off track

Giving students personalized attention in large high schools continues to be a challenge.

By by Paul Jablow on Apr 5, 2013 07:55 PM
Photo: Harvey Finkle

Angel Sostre says he was shuffled around as a 9th grader but has thrived in an alternative school.

Sheila Hernandez was 15 when she quit Frankford High School in the 9th grade. There was a lot of fighting in the school, and Hernandez, a slight girl with her hair cut short, was also bullied over her appearance.

When she had problems academically, she said, “I’d ask for help, and they wouldn’t give it to you.”

Damaries Rodriguez got pregnant in 9th grade and dropped out of Franklin Learning Center because she found she had too much work to make up when she returned.

Angel Sostre found 9th grade at Edison High School to be a miserable experience, because “they kept changing my roster. They kept changing teachers, and I had trouble keeping up to the work.” He lasted only a short while in 10th grade before leaving school.

Unlike most dropouts from the Philadelphia schools, all three are now in alternative high schools designed to give students a second chance at earning a diploma – Hernandez at El Centro de Estudiantes in Norris Square, and Rodriguez and Sostre at the Fairhill campus of One Bright Ray Community High School. 

But like many dropouts, they are living examples of how the 9th grade in Philadelphia and other major cities remains the place where the most students get sidetracked from the path toward graduation. 

Educators and administrators cite both lack of resources and lack of creative vision as reasons this 9th-grade problem remains unsolved today. 

A 2010 Research for Action report on the freshman year called for District-level changes, saying the system “inhibits the ability of neighborhood high schools to organize themselves to support new 9th graders.” 

Charles Baltimore, the new principal of Edison High School, said the schools themselves must change. 

“We’re trying to drive a 2013 car with a 1965 engine, and it’s not going to work,” he said. “Ninth grade is unique. [Students] are coming from a more self-contained culture. The academic demands step up a couple of notches. 

“They’re dealing with deaths, parents being separated, dad in jail, mom in jail. ... We’re not dealing with the trauma the kids bring in the door. ... We say, ‘Sit there for eight hours, learn the content, be respectful and come back tomorrow.’ It doesn’t work like that.”

According to data from Project U-Turn, a citywide anti-dropout campaign managed by the Philadelphia Youth Network, roughly one-third of the District’s 9th graders in 2011-12 were “off track” to graduate – likely to drop out. That’s more than in any other grade.

Off-track 9th graders were defined as those who met at least one of four criteria:

  • failed an English course;
  • failed a math course;
  • earned less than five credits;
  • had attendance of less than 70 percent. 

“Even students who were doing moderately well in the middle grades can be knocked off the path to graduation by the new academic demands and social pressures of high school,” wrote researchers Ruth Curran Neild, Robert Balfanz and Liza Herzog in a 2007 article in the journal Educational Leadership. 

Students may be asked to help out at home as caregivers or even wage-earners, girls may become pregnant, and a high-school-age student hanging out on the corner on a school day draws less attention than a 6th grader would. 

“When you’re an adolescent, you have more choices,” Herzog, who is research director at the Philadelphia Education Fund, said in an interview. “You get more knowledgeable about what’s out there.” 

Marcus Delgado, chief executive officer of One Bright Ray, agrees. “Ninth grade is where more freedoms come out, and that’s where the ‘explosion’ happens.”

The warning signs, though, are there early. “In Philadelphia,” Herzog said, “we can identify 75 percent of the future dropouts as early as 6th grade.” 

A study that followed 13,000 Philadelphia students from 1996 to 2004 identified key early warning indicators. For instance, it found that of 6th graders who average one or more absences a week, just 13 percent graduated on time. With more than one “flag,” the graduation rates were even lower. 

Most are still in school when 9th grade starts. 

But, like Angel Sostre, they often find themselves thrust into a more bewildering and impersonal atmosphere, particularly in large, neighborhood high schools. 

“There’s so much going on in their heads, and we’re putting them in the most dispassionate places,” said David Bromley, executive director of Big Picture Philadelphia, which runs El Centro de Estudiantes.

Sostre, Hernandez, and Rodriguez, all about to graduate from alternative schools, say they have thrived there because they have received a level of individual attention that they did not get in the large, traditional schools where they started.

“Here, you can pull anyone aside and ask for help,” Rodriguez said.

Neighborhood schools can do a better job in providing an individualized atmosphere, Herzog said. It would help simply to make sure that the teachers get more common planning time, particularly for any student clearly in danger of dropping out. 

“It’s working together to get a more holistic understanding of what’s going on in that student’s life,” she said. “It sounds so basic, but it’s rarely done.”

Herzog and others say that much of what needs to be done is basic, but it runs up against bureaucracy, habit, and lack of resources.

The 2010 Research for Action study found that neighborhood high schools were filled with 9th graders who had tried unsuccessfully to select a different school. Compounding that problem, the neighborhood schools were late to receive any information about the 9th graders who would be arriving in the fall.

But Marlene Owens, who deals directly with dropout issues as director of the Smaller Learning Communities program for the School District, has seen positive changes from the Summer Bridge program that brings incoming 9th graders to the high school they will be attending for five weeks of instruction and orientation.

Her office also heads the RTII (Response to Instruction and Intervention) program, which uses federal grant funds in 11 large high schools with low test scores. 

The program funds staff who “bring the behavior and the academic side together,” she said. “We haven’t always done that.”

The grant funds, however, run out in September. Owens said the District will apply for a one-year extension.

Given its budget crisis, the District will also be looking for cost-free improvements. One has been in place for years now – having 9th-grade students in the larger high schools housed together on the same floor.

More important, Owens said, is attention to who is teaching the 9th-grade remedial courses. 

“When we put them into place a few years ago,” she said, “some of the teachers [who were assigned] saw it as punishment. Now principals understand that we need their great teachers in the intervention classes.”

Lisa Nutter, president of the nonprofit Philadelphia Academies, warns, however, that the remedial work must be “contextualized so it isn’t boring. ... The students need to see the relevance of what they’re doing.” 

Nutter’s program aims to engage students by creating small, career-oriented schools within schools, enrolling some 3,000 students in 13 schools, including eight neighborhood high schools. 

She said she would prefer to start the model in 9th grade, but has been asked in most of the neighborhood schools to wait until the 10th so remedial work can be completed beforehand. 

Meanwhile, the changes in the shrinking District are already taking their toll. With the closing of several high schools, some of the schools receiving new students may be unable to offer the Summer Bridge program as they prepare for the transition. 

Several initiatives started under Hite’s predecessor, the late Arlene Ackerman, including additional school counselors, were funded with federal stimulus money that is gone.

Edison’s principal, Baltimore has six counselors for some 1,200 students, but two are supported by federal grants that may soon expire. When he goes to principals’ meetings, he hears that “the budget cuts have crippled some schools. No police, no NTAs (non-teaching assistants).” 

But Baltimore said that much can still be done within the confines of tight District budgets: “I play the hand I’m dealt,” he said.

He is seeking approval of the School Advisory Council to have teachers in grades 9 through 11 move through high school with their students. He hopes to have career and technical education students help rehab two abandoned houses in the neighborhood and – in partnership with social service and community organizations – convert them into group homes for students who are homeless or in destructive home environments.

Both Edison and One Bright Ray partner with Congreso, a social service organization for Latinos. Delgado said that the key to preventing dropouts in the 9th grade – or any grade – is partnerships with social service and mental health agencies and other community groups. 

“It would be wrong to say it’s 100 percent the School District’s fault,” said Delgado. “The problem isn’t going to be solved from 7 to 3.

“No student wakes up in the morning and says, ‘I want to be a dropout today.’” 

About the Author

Paul Jablow is a regular freelance contributor to the Notebook

Comments (22)

Submitted by AnonEldrige (not verified) on April 5, 2013 9:01 pm
According to their website, Mr. Charles Baltimore's high school has plumbing, electrical, and welding, but not carpentry or building technologies' programs. Why is he so interested in having students leave the safety of school to work in abandoned houses with out proper training?
Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on April 5, 2013 9:16 pm
To get to eight grade the criteria is to breath. To get from 9th to 10th, five credits are needed. This is the downfall of most of the students entering high schools.
Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on April 5, 2013 10:36 pm
Teachers of elementary and middle schoolers teach the grade level curriculum, reach back and fill in the gaps where students are weak and take them as far as they can in the 180 days that they have them as students. It is demeaning and dismissive of their work to say that all a student does is "breathe" and he gets to go to high school. Recent studies have shown that there is a high level of deep poverty in our city. Deep poverty has an adverse effect a child's readiness to learn. Let's stop blaming each other. Each effective teacher in Philly is going above and beyond. No child "breathes" his way to high school.
Submitted by K.R. Luebbert on April 5, 2013 10:36 pm
Agreed. As a 7th and 8th grade teacher, I hold students to high standards to pass, let alone to get an "A" or "B". We are a good school with a committed staff that try to give students the help they need. Sometimes, we cannot get students help or up to level because the parents refuse to agree to any supports or testing. We have parents refuse to allow students to stay for free tutoring after school because they have to take care of younger siblings, we have parent whose kids are desperately behind and struggling refuse to allow testing.I have 8th graders in this situation right now. We have been trying to get one of my 8th graders help since second grade. The parent will not agree. The student will go to high school several years behind even though we have done the best we can without the additional supports Special Ed would provide.
Submitted by Poogie (not verified) on April 6, 2013 11:30 am
My 11th and 12th grade classes are full of kids reading at or below the 6th grade level. Even the advanced students are not at grade level. Is this all the fault of teachers?? I am not sure. None of my kids read books, magazines or newspapers at home. Nor do the parents participate in the educational process. We have parent night, report card days and other functions and have under 10% attendance. In my suburban school district if I want a space in the huge parking lot outside my daughter's school for a parent function; I need to get there at least an hour ahead of time. While I will concede that some teachers do not do a good job at preparing kids for high school the bigger problem is at home. If Parents/guardians put more effort into their own kids we would not have today's crisis.
Submitted by Education Grad ... on April 6, 2013 5:06 pm
K.R., I have seen children who need special ed services, but the parents won't get them help. For example, I worked with one kid who needed to be in a Life Skills Support program, but was in Learning Support because the parents wanted him to stay at the same school as his siblings. He could have been bused to the school with the LSS program! Also, the school had been trying for 1.5 years to have the parents come in for an IEP meeting, and they had not come. I worked with a kid who had severe behavioral issues and the mother was in denial about her child. She had another child with more severe special needs and didn't want to have another child who was also in special ed. It's hard because the ball is in the parent's court. If they don't do the right thing or if they can't admit that their child needs serious help, it's hard for the school to do much. And forget about getting a court order in Philadelphia, because that's not happening. EGS
Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on April 6, 2013 10:38 am
Agreed that most of the K-8 teachers do a great job in preparing their students for high school but they cannot stop a student from moving to 9th grade. Many students come to high school unprepared to succeed. Then in high school they need the credits to get to 10th grade and that is the problem. Bridge programs and tutoring help but the student has to be willing to spend the time needed to take the programs. All of the reason for failure stated in the article are legitimate and hinder a students success. However five credits are still needed to pass to the next grade and age is not a factor.
Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on April 6, 2013 4:13 pm
The district just extended its deadline for parents of students in schools slated for closure to apply for different placements in September. Why was a two week extension needed? Because even with the news that the school they send their child to each morning is CLOSING in June, too many parents cannot be bothered to go into the school building and fill out the paperwork.
Submitted by Anonymous#1 (not verified) on April 7, 2013 8:16 am
Sad but most likely true. Two many parents are way too complacent when it comes to their children's education. It's always somebody else's responsibility. My favorite question is, "how am I suppose to get my kids to that school 6 blocks away". Really.... how about walking.
Submitted by Clip in Hair Extensions (not verified) on September 27, 2013 3:46 am
Howdy, i read your blog from time to time and i own a similar one and i was just wondering if you get a lot of spam feedback? If so how do you stop it, any plugin or anything you can advise? I get so much lately it's driving me crazy so any help is very much appreciated.
Submitted by ANNONYMOUS (not verified) on April 8, 2013 3:45 am
Ninth grade has been a transition concern for decades. Students are maturing and they are more vulnerable to peer pressure. Maybe the 7-9 school model that was in Philadelphia until the early 1990s was better. There is a difference between most 9th and 10th graders. In general, a maturation process happens in 9th grade. I've seen this as a parent and teacher. How we work with 9th graders should be different from 10th graders. It is more complicated in Philly because in many neighborhood schools, 9th graders are often 15 - 16 years old rather than 14.
Submitted by Tylerlee (not verified) on April 16, 2015 5:58 am

What a nice post which you have published here. This website have also so many useful and informative articles. Keep sharing such stuff here.  Safety Flooring

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on July 16, 2015 9:52 am

To get to eight grade the criteria is to breath. To get from 9th to 10th, five credits are needed. This is the downfall of most of the students entering high schools. clothing manufacturer

Submitted by alat pembesar payudara (not verified) on October 16, 2016 4:19 pm

jika istri anda kurang bergairah silahkan coba obat perangsang wanita Blue Wizard ASLI. jika istri anda kurang bergairah silahkan coba obat perangsang wanita Blue Wizard asli. pembesar payudara jika istri anda kurang bergairah silahkan coba obat perangsang wanita Blue Wizard. gunakan juga obat perangsang wanita alami. aneka obat pembesar alat vital pria terbaik

Submitted by Jimmy (not verified) on April 29, 2017 2:10 am

read more here

head over here

Submitted by lionel (not verified) on July 18, 2017 6:46 am

Babylon Tours Louvre Museum I am agreeing to your opinion. 9th grade is definitely an important period of the career of an individual. The most interesting part is that most of them fall of the track at this period. I think the best thing is to seek the advice from the experts.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on November 7, 2017 11:56 pm

“When you’re an adolescent, you have more choices,” Herzog, who is research director at the Philadelphia Education Fund, said in an interview. “You get more knowledgeable about what’s out there.” !!

happy wheels online, clicker heroes online

Submitted by Mike (not verified) on November 16, 2017 11:50 am

Thanks for sharing . Do write more helpful post soon. caridee

Submitted by Mike (not verified) on November 16, 2017 11:23 am

Thanks for sharing this nice post. caridee

Submitted by Mike (not verified) on November 18, 2017 9:57 am

Thanks for the great content. This site is really helpful . short quotes.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on December 13, 2017 7:14 am

Children nowadays not giving much priority to syllabus based academic activities. I think they are interested in practical sessions. Because of this dropout from the schools are gradually increasing day by day. Both systems are good for good future and so the school officials give students proper by Cory video production makeup artist

Submitted by Septic Tank Ramah Lingkungan (not verified) on January 20, 2018 8:53 am

Wonderfull, Visit Back:

Jual septic tank ramah lingkungan seperti septic tank Biotech

 dan septic tank Bio


Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

By using this service you agree not to post material that is obscene, harassing, defamatory, or otherwise objectionable. We reserve the right to delete or remove any material deemed to be in violation of this rule, and to ban anyone who violates this rule. Please see our "Terms of Usage" for more detail concerning your obligations as a user of this service. Reader comments are limited to 500 words. You are fully responsible for the content that you post.

Table of Contents

Read the latest print issue

Philly Ed Feed


Public School Notebook

699 Ranstead St.
Third Floor
Philadelphia, PA 19106
Phone: (215) 839-0082
Fax: (215) 238-2300

© Copyright 2013 The Philadelphia Public School Notebook. All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Usage and Privacy Policy